Search

Gibson Assembly vs Golden Gate: A Complete Guide to Choosing the Right Cloning Method

CLYTE research team
Oct 1
4 min read

In the world of molecular biology, the ability to piece together DNA fragments is fundamental. Two of the most powerful and popular methods for this are Gibson Assembly and Golden Gate Cloning. While both techniques are used to create custom DNA constructs, they operate on different principles and each has its own set of strengths and weaknesses. This article will provide a detailed comparison of these two methods to help you decide which one is the best fit for your next cloning experiment.

You might also want to watch this very fun animation about Biofilms! You might also be interested in learning more biomedical assays from Sophie!

At a Glance: Gibson Assembly vs. Golden Gate Cloning

Feature	Gibson Assembly	Golden Gate Cloning
Enzymes Used	Exonuclease, DNA polymerase, DNA ligase	Type IIS restriction enzymes, T4 DNA ligase
Mechanism	Homologous recombination	Restriction-ligation
Seamless/Scarless	Yes	Yes
Number of Fragments	Up to 15 fragments	Up to 30+ fragments
Fragment Size	Flexible, but fragments <200bp can be problematic	Flexible, including short fragments
Vector Compatibility	Any vector that can be linearized	Requires vectors with Type IIS recognition sites
Cost	Generally more expensive	Can be more cost-effective
Primer Design	Requires long primers with homologous overlaps	Standard PCR primers
Efficiency	High	Very high, especially for multi-fragment assemblies

What is Gibson Assembly?

Developed by Daniel Gibson in 2009, Gibson Assembly is a method that allows for the joining of multiple DNA fragments in a single, isothermal reaction. The magic behind this technique lies in a cocktail of three enzymes:

T5 Exonuclease: This enzyme "chews back" the 5' ends of the DNA fragments, creating single-stranded 3' overhangs.
Phusion DNA Polymerase: This polymerase fills in any gaps in the annealed DNA fragments.
Taq DNA Ligase: This ligase seals the nicks in the assembled DNA, creating a seamless, double-stranded DNA molecule.

For Gibson Assembly to work, the DNA fragments to be joined must have overlapping homologous sequences at their ends (typically 20-40 base pairs). These overlaps are usually added to the fragments during PCR amplification.

The Gibson Assembly Workflow:

Fragment Generation: DNA fragments are amplified by PCR using primers that add overlapping homologous sequences to their ends.
Assembly Reaction: The DNA fragments are mixed with the Gibson Assembly master mix containing the three enzymes.
Incubation: The reaction is incubated at 50°C for about an hour.
Transformation: The assembled DNA can be directly transformed into competent cells.

What is Golden Gate Cloning?

Golden Gate Cloning, also known as Golden Gate Assembly, is another powerful method for seamless DNA assembly. Unlike Gibson Assembly, Golden Gate Cloning relies on the unique properties of Type IIS restriction enzymes, such as BsaI and BsmBI. These enzymes are special because they cut DNA outside of their recognition sequence, allowing for the creation of unique, non-palindromic sticky ends.

The key to Golden Gate cloning is the design of the DNA fragments. Each fragment is flanked by a Type IIS recognition site and a unique 4-base pair overhang. When the fragments and a destination vector (which also contains Type IIS sites) are mixed with a Type IIS enzyme and T4 DNA ligase, a one-pot reaction occurs. The restriction enzyme cuts the DNA fragments and the vector, and the ligase then joins them together in the correct order, dictated by the complementary overhangs.

The Golden Gate Cloning Workflow:

Fragment Design: DNA fragments are designed with Type IIS recognition sites and unique overhangs.
Assembly Reaction: The DNA fragments, destination vector, Type IIS enzyme, and T4 DNA ligase are all combined in a single tube.
Thermal Cycling: The reaction is cycled between temperatures that favor digestion and ligation, driving the assembly process forward.
Transformation: The final, assembled plasmid is transformed into competent cells.

Head-to-Head: Which Method Reigns Supreme?

Both Gibson Assembly and Golden Gate Cloning are powerful tools, but they excel in different areas. Here's a breakdown of their key differences:

Mechanism: Gibson Assembly is based on homologous recombination, while Golden Gate Cloning is a restriction-ligation-based method.
Scarless Assembly: Both methods are capable of creating seamless, "scarless" constructs, meaning no unwanted extra DNA sequences are left behind at the junctions of the fragments.
Number of Fragments: Golden Gate Cloning generally has the upper hand when it comes to assembling a large number of fragments. It can reliably assemble 30 or more fragments in a single reaction, while Gibson Assembly is typically limited to around 15 fragments.
Fragment Size: Gibson Assembly is very flexible in terms of the size of the DNA fragments, but it can be inefficient for fragments smaller than 200 base pairs. Golden Gate Cloning, on the other hand, can handle a wide range of fragment sizes, including very short ones.
Vector Compatibility: Gibson Assembly is more flexible in terms of vector choice, as any vector that can be linearized can be used. Golden Gate Cloning requires specific destination vectors that contain the appropriate Type IIS recognition sites.
Efficiency and Cost: Golden Gate cloning is often considered more efficient and cost-effective, especially for high-throughput and multi-fragment assemblies.

Choosing Your Cloning Champion: A Practical Guide

So, which method should you choose? Here's a quick guide:

Use Gibson Assembly when:
- You are assembling a moderate number of fragments (2-6).
- You are working with large DNA fragments.
- You need flexibility in your choice of vector.
Use Golden Gate Cloning when:
- You are assembling a large number of fragments (>6).
- You are performing high-throughput or combinatorial cloning.
- You are working with small DNA fragments.

The Final Verdict

Both Gibson Assembly and Golden Gate Cloning are indispensable tools for the modern molecular biologist. The best method in Gibson Assembly vs Golden Gate for you will ultimately depend on the specific needs of your experiment. By understanding the principles and nuances of each technique, you can make an informed decision and set yourself up for cloning success.

Find more articles like this and 100s of SOPs here!

References